Looking for safe eyeliner for lash extensions? Choosing the right eyeliner is crucial to maintain the health and longevity of your extensions. In this article, we’ll explore the top liners that are safe to use with eyelash extensions. Whether you’re a makeup pro or a beginner, this guide will help you find the perfect eyeliner for your needs.
What Type Of Eyeliners Are Best For Lash Extensions?
When it comes to choosing safe eyeliner for lash extensions, there are a few key things to keep in mind. Avoid using oil-based eyeliners, as they can break down the adhesive used to attach the extensions. Instead, opt for water-based or gel eyeliners, which are gentle on lashes and easy to remove. These formulas provide long-lasting wear without compromising the health of your extensions.
Top Safe Eyeliner For Lash Extensions
Here are the best oil-free eyeliners for lash extensions that are water-based and can be easily removed without an oil-based cleanser, and are safe for lash extensions.
Best Liquid Eyeliner For Lash Extensions
1. SIDE CHICK Eyeliner
The SIDE CHICK Eyeliner is specifically made for those with eyelash extensions. Its highly pigmented formula creates bold lines without risking damage to your lashes. The long-lasting, smudge-proof formula ensures your look stays put all day.
The fine-tip applicator makes for easy, precise application, perfect for creating winged lines or cat-eye looks. Plus, it’s cruelty-free and made in the USA.
However, since it’s so long-lasting, you’ll need a lash extension-safe cleanser, like the TLC eyelash cleanser, to properly remove it.
2. Kat Von D Tattoo Liner
This eyeliner lasts long, resists smudging, and is waterproof, just as it claims. It has a very fine brush tip for precise lines, and its flexible tip allows for both thin and thick lines. You can create different looks with this eyeliner, not just the usual eyeliner styles.
However, it might be a bit difficult to apply over eyeshadow, and without eyeshadow primer, it might not work well on oily eyelids. Some people have also found that the eyeliner can dry out over time.
You might want to try the One Size liner as an alternative, which is also highly praised for its dark black color, no feathering, and easy application.
3. Prolong Lash Liner
Prolong Lash Oil-Free Eyeliner offers intense black pigment with a satin finish, perfect for creating precise lines. It’s safe for use with eyelash extensions, as it’s free from damaging oils. The liner glides on smoothly with its soft tip, providing a dark, defined look. However, it may fade throughout the day, requiring reapplication.
Verified Customer (Prolong Lash)
Best oil free eyeliner! I include it in my deluxe after care kits for my clients and they love it🤍 definitely recommended.
4. Kiko Milano Precision Eyeliner
This liquid eyeliner features a felt applicator for precise application. It’s long-lasting and dries quickly, creating an ultra-defined line. However, it’s not completely transfer-proof and would benefit from being more water-resistant.
Florina (KIKO Cosmeetics)
In the last 5 years this one is the only eyeliner I use. I wear it every day, all day. It’s easy to apply. The best!
5. NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liquid Liner
The NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liquid Liner offers an intense, long-lasting color that’s perfect for both face and body. Its waterproof formula ensures it stays put, even in hot weather or at festivals.
The fine brush tip allows for precise application, whether you’re creating subtle lines or bold, graphic looks.
However, some users have found the formula to be clumpy and challenging to apply, while others have experienced smudging and transferring, especially on oily or hooded eyelids.
Despite these drawbacks, the liner is cruelty-free, which means it’s not tested on animals and it also offers a range of colors.
6. Honest Beauty Long-Lasting Vegan Liquid Eyeliner
This ultra-pigmented black liquid eyeliner offers a high-impact look with its bold color formula. The flexible felt brush tip applicator allows for easy and precise application, from the inner to the outer corner of the eye.
It is gentle enough for sensitive eyes, made with plant-derived ingredients, and free from parabens, carbon black pigment, silicones, and PEGs. The eyeliner is ophthalmologist-tested, hypoallergenic, cruelty-free, vegan, and dermatologist-tested.
It provides a satiny smooth finish that stays in place for up to 8 hours. However, it may be difficult to clean and requires a cleanser for removal.
7. e.l.f. Expert Liquid Liner
The e.l.f. Expert Liquid Liner features an extra-fine brush tip for precise application without tugging or skipping. Its smudge-proof formula delivers bold, pigmented color in three shades, offering long-lasting definition from thin to thick lines.
However, opinions are mixed: some find it long-lasting and easy to apply, while others have experienced issues with the felt tip drying out or the liner bleeding and smudging. The liner is vegan and free from harmful chemicals.
For an alternative, consider the Wet n Wild Break Up Proof Liquid Liner.
8. Clinique Quickliner For Eyes Intense
The Clinique Quickliner for Eyes Intense is a twist-up eyeliner that glides on smoothly and doesn’t require sharpening. Its creamy formula is transfer-resistant and stays put all day without fading.
You can smudge, blend, or correct the liner within sixty seconds of application before it sets. This eyeliner is water-resistant, ophthalmologist-tested, and allergy-tested, making it suitable for sensitive eyes. It’s fragrance-free and is said to improve skin without irritation.
However, cleaning it might be hard, and you’ll need a cleanser to remove it.
9. LBLA Cosmetics Everlasting Eyeliner
Ultra-Fine Felt Tip Liner is the safest eyeliner for lash extensions. It’s smudge-proof and water-resistant, providing intense, rich pigment that lasts up to 12 hours. The liner glides effortlessly for a smooth application. It’s long-wearing and won’t damage lashes or lash adhesives. To remove, use a brush and eyelash extension safe cleansers or makeup remover.
Verified Customer (LBLA Cosmetics)
I’m a liquid eyeliner snob and as a professional MUA as well I’m always in search of eyeliner that glides on smoothly, sets quickly, and won’t transfer to anything through wear. I can honestly say I stock up on these in bulk and give them to friends and clients just because I know everyone will benefit from it. A++
Best Gel Eyeliner For Lash Extensions
1. Melt Cosmetics Gel Eyeliner
Melt Cosmetics Gel Eyeliner is a vegan eyeliner with an irresistible formula that sets on your eyes, not in the jar, ensuring no more dried-out pots. It glides on effortlessly, creating sharp lines for bold, long-wearing wings.
The multi-use formula allows for blending before it sets, acting like a cream shadow for an intense all-over black-out. However, some users have reported that it tends to flake, even when the lid is kept extra tight. It is available in a range of colors.
2. Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner
This gel-based, waterproof eyeliner offers the precision of a liquid liner. Its color stays true for long hours, giving a subtle yet dramatic look. It provides ultra-precise, budge-proof, smudge-proof, and fade-proof definition, making it a must-have for artists.
This highly pigmented liner allows you to create subtle to dramatic looks effortlessly, with 8-hour wear. However, some users may find it challenging to remove due to its long-lasting formula but which can be removed using lash extension safe cleanser.
Naureen (Bobbi Brown Cosmetics)
I have not found anything better than this. It glides smoothly and stays on forever. Love it, using it since 2005.
3. MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot Eyeshadow
It’s a cream eyeshadow, but it’s also safe to use as an eyeliner with lash extensions. This long-wearing formula is blendable and can be worn alone or with other products. It has been ophthalmologist and dermatologist tested, ensuring it is safe for sensitive skin and eyes.
The shadow is non-caking, non-flaking, and non-creasing, providing 24-hour wear. It is water-resistant and provides flexible coverage, staying true to color. Additionally, it is free of phthalates, parabens, formaldehyde donors, SLS, SLES, triclosan, D&C Yellow No. 11, oxybenzone, and synthetic microbeads 5mm or smaller.
However, it can be quite dry, so you need to work fast as it dries.
How To Apply Eyeliner On Lash Extensions
- Choose the Right Eyeliner: Opt for a water-based or gel eyeliner that is safe for use with lash extensions. Avoid oil-based formulas as they can weaken the bond of the lash adhesive.
- Prepare Your Lash Line: Ensure your lash extensions are clean and dry. If you have oily lids, use an oil-free makeup remover before applying eyeliner.
- Apply the Eyeliner: Use a fine-tipped brush or a precision eyeliner pen to apply the eyeliner along the base of your lash line. Avoid applying too much pressure to prevent loosening the lash extensions.
- Avoid the Roots: Do not apply eyeliner directly on the roots of the lash extensions. Instead, focus on the skin between the lashes for a natural look.
How To Remove Eyeliner On Lash Extensions
To remove eyeliner while wearing eyelash extensions, follow these steps:
- Use an oil-free, lash extension-safe makeup remover or foaming lash wash. Avoid oil-based products as they can cause the lash adhesive to break down prematurely.
- Dip a soft, fluffy brush or cotton swab into the makeup remover. Be careful not to oversaturate it.
- Gently brush or dab the remover along your lash line to dissolve the eyeliner. Avoid excessive rubbing or pulling on the lash extensions.
- Use a clean, dry cotton swab or tissue to wipe away the dissolved makeup residue.
- Rinse the area with water and pat dry with a clean towel to remove any remaining remover
Best Eye Makeup Remover For Lash Extensions
As we’ve discussed safe eyeliner for lash extensions, it’s important to also use gentle eye makeup cleansers to protect your lashes when removing eye makeup. Gentle products are crucial to avoid damaging eyelash extensions.
The best eye makeup remover for lash extensions are Garnier SkinActive Micellar Foaming Cleanser, Prolong Lash Cleanser, LBLA Cosmetics Bubble Lash Shampoo, TLC eyelash cleanser, or Lyon Lash Foaming Cleanser.
These cleansers are ideal for lash extensions as they are gentle, effective, and designed to keep lashes healthy. They remove eye makeup without damaging extensions and are free from harmful ingredients like oils, parabens, and sulfates, ensuring they won’t harm your lashes.
Conclusion
Finding the best safe eyeliner for lash extensions doesn’t have to be difficult. By choosing a water-based or gel formula and following our tips for application and removal, you can enjoy beautiful lashes without compromising the lash’s health. Experiment with different brands and formulas to find the perfect liner for your unique style and needs.
Related Posts You May Like
